Let’s discuss feature planning, picking and complexity.
To catch the pace, we keep adding features and building complex systems. Thinking, “This will be useful” or “What if we need this in the future?” But often, those extra features end up unused, complicating the code, and slowing down the project. This is where YAGNI, which stands for “You Aren’t Gonna Need It,” comes in.
What Is YAGNI?
YAGNI is a concept from Agile and Extreme Programming (XP) methodologies. It states that don’t add functionality until you actually need it. While it might seem smart to build for future possibilities, it often leads to over-engineering—making things more complicated than they need to be.
“Always implement things when you actually need them, never when you just foresee that you need them.” – Ron Jeffries, one of the founders of XP
Examples of YAGNI in Action
- Over-Architecting a User Authentication System
Imagine you’re building a web application with a user authentication system. You might be tempted to implement a complex, multi-tiered authentication system with social logins, two-factor authentication, and a password recovery mechanism. However, if your application is still in its early stages, with a small user base, such complexity might not be necessary.
By adhering to YAGNI, you could start with a simple email/password authentication system. As your user base grows and the need for more robust security features becomes apparent, you can then iteratively add the necessary components. This approach allows you to ship your product faster and avoid spending time and resources on features that might not be needed in the immediate future.
- Premature Optimization in Code
Developers often feel the urge to optimize code early, ensuring it’s as efficient as possible from the get-go. However, optimizing code before it’s clear where the performance bottlenecks lie can be a waste of time.
- Building Features for Hypothetical Future Use Cases
YAGNI advises you to hold off on building feature until you have a clear demand for it from your users. This approach helps you avoid unnecessary complexity and keeps your codebase lean and focused on delivering the core functionality that your users need right now.
Pros and Cons of YAGNI
Pros:
Simplifies Codebase:
- YAGNI helps keep your codebase lean by avoiding unnecessary features. This makes the code easier to understand, maintain, and extend.
Faster Development:
- By focusing only on what’s needed, you can deliver features and products more quickly.
Cost Efficiency:
- Time and resources are spent on features that provide immediate value, reducing the overall cost of development and maintenance.
Improves Flexibility:
- With a lean codebase, it’s easier to pivot or adapt to changes in user needs or business requirements.
Cons:
Potential for Short-Term Thinking:
- Focusing too much on the present can lead to missed opportunities for future-proofing. Some features might be more difficult or costly to add later.
Risk of Technical Debt:
- If you delay too many features, you might end up with a backlog of work that becomes technical debt, which can be difficult to address later on.
Possible Rework:
- Avoiding features until they are needed might result in rework or refactoring if the system wasn’t originally designed with future needs in mind.
Balancing Act:
- It can be challenging to strike the right balance between avoiding unnecessary work and planning for future needs. Overemphasis on YAGNI might leave a project unprepared for growth or change.
So, it’s not about implementing the YAGNI principle completely in your project, it’s about finding the balance.